Link to About American Business Appraisers, LLP of San Francisco Link to Business Valuation Services Link to Litigation Support Services Link to Business Consulting Services Link to Valuation Seminars Link to the Home Page of American Business Appraisers, LLP of San Francisco
American Business Appraisers, LLP of San Francisco
Link to Business Valuation Articles Link to Business Valuation Case Studies Link to Testimonials from Clients Link to a Sampling of Completed Transactions

  Marketability Misconceptions

Marketability = Liquidity. The notion of a discount to value based on the marketability of the subject property has been around for a long time, and is based in fundamental proposition that the market craves liquidity and loathes the absence of it. All else equal, a liquid (marketable, as if freely traded) investment should be worth more than an illiquid (less marketable, not freely traded) one. Actual performance of the market clearly demonstrates this phenomenon.

Marketability = Risk. The concept of a marketability discount seems to suggest the value of the subject business should be less because no one would want to buy it. The managing spouse often protests that the business should have a marketability discount because it’s not making money. But technically, this is incorrect: the desirability of the subject business as an investment should be addressed in the required rate of return (i.e. the capitalization rate or the discount rate). Less desirable businesses are riskier investments, so investors would require a higher rate of return on the expected income stream, irrespective of the size or velocity of the marketplace.

Discount Always Relative
. For the business appraiser, marketability discounts, (more properly, adjustments for lack of liquidity or for difference of marketability) are critical to the accuracy of the valuation result. But the key thing to remember is that the marketability discounts are always relative to some reference point of value. For example, if the appraiser relies on transactions of public stock (a common benchmark for liquidity) as a source for the development of the discount rate, then the resulting value of the subject business is its value as if were as liquid as publicly traded stocks (which it is not). Without an adjustment to match the marketability (liquidity) of the subject business to the publicly traded stocks that were used as the basis for the discount rate, the value of the subject business may be significantly over-stated.

Marketability Discount is Internal. In this sense, the marketability discount may be said to be internal to the methodology selected by the appraiser, and not closely related to the characteristics of the subject business except insofar as it is less liquid (i.e. would take longer to convert to cash than publicly traded stocks). In the conventional sense, the marketability adjustment only arises because the appraiser uses the rate of return obtained by investors in publicly traded stocks as the source for the benchmark rate of return in his discount-rate development. Were he to use a rate of return obtained by investors in privately-held entities - for example buyers/holders of shares in private corporations - as the benchmark rate of return, no such marketability adjustment would be required because the liquidity of the source for the benchmark rate is the same as the liquidity of the subject ownership interest. This is a watershed change in thinking (though not a new concept by any means) for many lay-thinkers.

Measuring the Discount. Once the decision has been made to rely on trades of publicly traded stocks as the source for the benchmark rate of return, the appraiser must next take steps to measure the extent of discount from the “as if freely traded” value that results form the application of the benchmark-based discount rate. There are a couple of good ways to measure the size of the discount to apply, and we’ll address these in a future issue.

Business Valuation Articles
  Good Business Intermediaries Can Attract the Right Investors
Marketability Misconceptions
   More Marketability Misconceptions
   In re: Marriage of Hewitson
  Selecting a Business Appraisal Firm
  Forensic Accounting in Divorce Matters
  Standard of Value is Everything
  Why is the Date of Valuation Important
  In re: Marriage of Duncan
  Why do we take a Minority Discount
  What’s the Difference Between a Control Premium and a Minority Discount
  What is “Fair Value” Anyway
  Mart v. Severson
  ABCs of Appraiser Credentials
  “Core Earnings” Measure Alters Landscape
  What is USPAP
  How much Should a Business Appraisal Cost
  What is Investment Value Anyway
  Mediation-Valuation gives parties opportunity to “work-through” valuation    to reach compromise
  What is Forensic Accounting
  Current Lessons for U.S. Equity Investors
  Apportionment Methods - Pereira-VanCamp
  Highest and Best Use..
  Minority Shareholder Oppression – Fraud Investigation
  What's Real?
  Report Types and Level of Service
  Testimony and the Valuation Expert
  The Art of the Deal
  INC. Magazine article: What is your company worth NOW?
American Business Appraisers, LLP
3800 Blackhawk Road, Suite 140, Danville, California 94506
Phone: (925) 964-0370 • Fax: (925) 964-0374
E-mail American Business Appraisers, LLP
  © Copyright American Business Appraisers, LLP ® All Rights Reserved