Link to About American Business Appraisers, LLP of San Francisco Link to Business Valuation Services Link to Litigation Support Services Link to Business Consulting Services Link to Valuation Seminars Link to the Home Page of American Business Appraisers, LLP of San Francisco
American Business Appraisers, LLP of San Francisco
Link to Business Valuation Articles Link to Business Valuation Case Studies Link to Testimonials from Clients Link to a Sampling of Completed Transactions
 
         

  In re: Marriage of Duncan

Use of Alternative date of valuation under Family Code §2552(a) proper where professional post-separation efforts result in increase in value of community-owned business.

This 2001 case out of San Diego addressed the question of whether an alternative date of valuation under Family Code §2552(a) requires that the change in value be related entirely to the post-separation efforts of the managing spouse.

The parties were married when they formed a pension investment firm in 1990. The company was managing over $1 billion in assets when the parties separated in 1994. Husband continued to operate the investment business after the date of separation. The trial court did not hear the valuation issues until 1997, by which time the investment portfolio of the company had increased substantially. Husband argued that because the increase in the size of the firm was due to his own post-separation efforts, the business should be valued as of the date of separation instead of the date of trial.

Wife asserted on appeal that the trial court’s use of the alternative date of valuation was improper because the post-separation increase in value was due to factors other than husband’s personal efforts.

In its analysis the appellate court reviewed the state of the law in California regarding the application of the alternative date of valuation provided for in Family Code §2552(a). “Case law has established that good cause generally exists for a professional practice to be valued as of the date of separation.” (Marriage of Kilbourne (1991) 232 Cal.App.3d 1518 [valuation of law practice]; Marriage of Green, (1989) 213 Cal.App.3d 20 [valuation of law practice].)

This exception applies because the value of such businesses “is primarily a reflection of the practitioner’s services and not capital assets… Because the earnings and accumulations following separation are the spouse’s separate property, it follows that the community interest should be valued as of the date of separation - the cutoff date for the acquisition of community assets.” (Marriage of Stevenson (1993) 20 Cal.App.4th 250, 253-254). Further, “[t]he rationale for the general exception is not limited to law practices. It applies with equal logic to other small businesses that rely on the skill and reputation of the [managing spouse].” (Marriage of Stevenson 20 Cal.App.4th at 254 [small general contracting business].) Thus an alternative date of valuation may apply to a business when its value “...devolves largely from the personal skill, industry and guidance of the [managing spouse].” (Ibid.)

Here the community company manifested all of the attributes of a professional practice, including performing a service for a fee, offering specialized knowledge and experience, being licensed and regulated, and having asset  that consist mostly of office equipment, accounts receivable, and work-in-progress.

Thus the value of the company derived not from its capital assets, but rather from the professional investment advisory services that husband provides to it. Nothing in Family Code §2552(a), the Court held, requires the trial judge to find that the entire post-separation change in value was due exclusively to the personal efforts of the operating spouse in order to apply an alternative valuation date.

 
   
Business Valuation Articles
 
 
  Good Business Intermediaries Can Attract the Right Investors
  Marketability Misconceptions
  More Marketability Misconceptions
 
 
  Selecting a Business Appraisal Firm
  Forensic Accounting in Divorce Matters
  Standard of Value is Everything!
  Why is the Date of Valuation Important?
 
In re: Marriage of Duncan
  Why do we take a Minority Discount
  What’s the Difference Between a Control Premium and a Minority Discount
  What is “Fair Value” Anyway
  Mart v. Severson
  ABCs of Appraiser Credentials
  “Core Earnings” Measure Alters Landscape
  What is USPAP
  How much Should a Business Appraisal Cost
  What is Investment Value Anyway
  Mediation-Valuation gives parties opportunity to “work-through” valuation    to reach compromise
  What is Forensic Accounting
  Current Lessons for U.S. Equity Investors
  Apportionment Methods - Pereira-VanCamp
  Highest and Best Use..
  Minority Shareholder Oppression – Fraud Investigation
  What's Real?
  Report Types and Level of Service
  Testimony and the Valuation Expert
  The Art of the Deal
  INC. Magazine article: What is your company worth NOW?
 
American Business Appraisers, LLP
3800 Blackhawk Road, Suite 140, Danville, California 94506
Phone: (925) 964-0370 • Fax: (925) 964-0374
E-mail American Business Appraisers, LLP
  © Copyright American Business Appraisers, LLP ® All Rights Reserved